Too sweet for our own good

4 min read

Panel lauds new labeling guidelines, takes aim at added sugar and salt in food, as well as some supplements

The United States is simply too sweet for its own good.

Even the “healthy” fruit drinks that Americans sip are packed with the amount of sugar in six cookies. That love affair is making us sick.

“There’s no question we consume too much sugar,” said Frank Hu, a professor of nutrition and epidemiology at the Harvard School of Public Health (HSPH). “It is not only bad for your teeth, it’s associated with increased risk of diabetes, hypertension, and is bad for your heart.”

Hu spoke at the HSPH panel “Sugar, Salt, and Supplements: Sorting the Science” on Monday, just weeks after the U.S. Food and Drug Administration announced its first overhaul of food-product labels in 20 years. The revamped labels will provide consumers with nutrition facts, calorie counts in boldface type, and realistic serving sizes. They also will also disclose how much sugar manufacturers add to their products, all with an eye toward helping the public make healthier eating choices.

The World Health Organization proposes reducing the daily sugar dose from 10 percent of calories to 5, the equivalent of eight teaspoons. Hu called it a “very ambitious but achievable goal.”

Hu, who is also a professor of medicine at Harvard Medical School (HMS) and Channing Lab at Brigham and Women’s Hospital, pointed to the health consequences of failing to act. Centers for Disease Control studies show that people who get more than 10 percent of their daily calories from products with added sugar had a 40 percent increased risk of dying of heart disease, Hu said.

Panelist Dariush Mozaffarian ’06, an associate professor in epidemiology at HSPH, warned that the dietary focus should also be on targeting “poor-quality carbohydrates” such as refined grains, potatoes, and sugar.

“Fifty percent of our calories come from poor-quality carbohydrates,” said Mozaffarian, an associate professor in cardiovascular medicine at HMS and Brigham and Women’s Hospital. “Mary Poppins said a spoonful of sugar helps the medicine go down. There’s a lot of good, healthy, whole-grain products with a little bit of added sugar … If we just use sugars (to gauge a product), we could get misled.”

Hu said the new labeling system would be a relatively easy way to count empty calories in sugar, compared with the more complicate tracking of refined starch in foods such as bagels and potatoes.  He also supports government programs like ones that ban sales of sugary drinks or large sodas.

“They increase awareness about this major public health problem,” Hu said. “There is no magic bullet.”

Panelist JoAnn Manson ’75, professor in epidemiology at HSPH and chief of preventive medicine at the Brigham, said the new food labels will prove critical to pressuring food manufacturers to reduce the levels of added sugar and salt.

“When consumers are making choices, it’s so important to have something that’s easily visible and can see differences,” said Manson. “That will put pressure [on companies] to develop foods with lower sugars and sodium. They’ll go with other options. Many consumers have no idea how much sugar and salt is in their food.”

The panel, presented in collaboration with the Huffington Post and moderated by its senior editor for health news, Amanda Chan, also addressed the latest scientific data on salt intake.

Mozaffarian called overuse of salt a “global health problem.” He said current guidelines range as high as 4 grams of sodium per day, but should be closer 1.5 to 2 grams. Sodium is injected into processed foods such as bread and meat so they stay fresh, he said. “All that can be reduced,” Mozaffarian added. “The government needs to do something.”

Some Americans try to make up for their bad eating habits by taking multivitamins and supplements like fish oil. Manson said everyone needs vitamin D, and the recommended adult guideline is 800 IUs (international units) with calcium for bone health. But the jury is still out on whether greater amounts might prevent cancer and cardiovascular disease. Testing is being done on doses of 2,000 IUs daily, she added. Still, Manson said the “jury is still out” as to whether many supplements are safe and effective.

“There will never be a replacement for a healthy, well-balanced diet,” Manson said.
[gz_video youtube_id=”ZJiYMHdr3p8″ title=”Sugar, Salt & Supplements”]A Harvard School of Public Health panel sorts out the science in Americans consumption of sugar, salt, and supplements. Courtesy of The Forum at the Harvard School of Public Health[/gz_video]