Sometimes you have to walk around in another person’s lab coat to really understand a problem.
In ES 227: “Medical Device Design,” engineering students are given the opportunity to solve practical problems in a hospital setting, trying out the tools, learning about their use in real-world situations, and, in some cases, even sitting in on surgical procedures.
Taught by Conor Walsh, a newly appointed assistant professor of mechanical and biomedical engineering at Harvard’s School of Engineering and Applied Sciences (SEAS), with help from teaching fellow Sam Kesner, the course connects the dots between engineering and medicine.
“SEAS has a lot of great facilities, expertly trained faculty, and eagerly motivated students — but it’s not a hospital,” says Paul Loschak, a graduate student in mechanical engineering whose team designed a portable cranial drill. Seeing the tools and procedures firsthand is essential, he says. “Otherwise, we’re doing nothing but making assumptions on top of assumptions, and no good products can come of that.”
That firsthand experience has paid off, as designs by undergraduate and graduate students who took the course in the spring have led to patents and publication.
“The goal of it,” says Kesner, “was to have the students go through the procedure as it is now. For example, how many people are in the room? What tools and components need to be sterile? Who opens the container? All of these details are essential for understanding how a device will be used.”
Brandon Hopkins ’11, William Marks ’12, and graduate students Qimin Quan and Huayin (Helen) Wu wanted to find a way to prevent “steal syndrome” in patients undergoing kidney dialysis. To facilitate dialysis, a special tube called a graft is implanted in the patient’s arm, allowing blood to be siphoned out of the body and then returned. In about 8 percent of cases, the graft “steals” too much blood, and circulation bypasses the hand, potentially resulting in tissue damage.
“It gave us a much better understanding of the setting, as well as details like the incision size,” says Wu.
“Having that access to the hospitals is key,” says Walsh, who will also join the Wyss Institute for Biologically Inspired Engineering at Harvard as a core faculty member. “You can listen to doctors explain their problem, but by watching them do something, you can really quickly see the opportunity for innovation.”
The open-ended nature of the class was made possible with a grant from the Center for Integration of Medicine & Innovative Technology (CIMIT), a Boston-based consortium of universities and teaching hospitals that supports translational research in clinical health care.
With the aims of CIMIT in mind, Walsh and Kesner acted as research and development project managers for the engineering students, mimicking the design process at professional engineering firms. Before the students jumped on any ideas, they were required to read the medical literature, meet with the doctors (who were treated as clients), and analyze the existing tools’ strengths and weaknesses.
“Early on in the process, it’s important for students to operate at a conceptual level and stick to back-of-the-envelope calculations,” says Walsh. “By the end of the course, they’ll have analytical models programmed in MATLAB or Excel and have detailed SolidWorks models of all of their components, ready to be sent out to a machine shop.”
The in-between part, of course, is where the real learning takes place; faculty and staff say their role is to help students blend creativity with a deterministic design process. Students must learn to analyze, evaluate, critique — and communicate — their own ideas before moving forward.
“At the start of the process, we never want a student team to come and say, ‘This is what we want to do. It’s the best way,’” says Walsh. “In design, if you can be your own best antagonist and come up with many competing concepts yourself, I think that’s really helpful, because you’ll end up learning something from the first idea that eventually leads you to a better solution.”
Loschak and classmates Kechao Xiao and Hao Pei chose to design a portable, hand-held drill that can safely create a hole in the skull without damaging the soft tissue inside. Cranial drills can be important for measuring and relieving pressure on the brain immediately after a severe head injury.
For any device, but especially for one intended to work so close to the brain, certain design parameters (e.g. how quickly the drill stops) are nonnegotiable, and some of the team’s initial ideas did not work. However, the students eventually came up with an ingenious mechanism in which the moment the drill penetrates the cranial cavity, the change in physical force makes the drill bit automatically retract.
“What this drill does is takes something that a neurosurgeon does, and makes it something that a paramedic or other medical professional can do,” said Ajith Thomas, chief of cerebrovascular surgery at Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, at the final project presentations in May. “I think it’s a truly marvelous thing that these guys have done.”
“Working so closely with a doctor was both enlightening and humbling,” says Loschak. After meeting with Thomas, Loschak, Xiao, and Pei would sketch some ideas on the bus ride back to campus, and perhaps build a quick prototype in one of the teaching labs. On the other hand, Loschak recalls, Thomas would “scrub into an operating room and save several patients’ lives for the rest of the day.”
“It’s a whole different world,” Loschak adds. “I’m honored that any clinicians want to spend their time designing a medical product with us.”
In fact, all the doctors involved were as excited and dedicated as the students, faculty, and staff at SEAS, devoting nights and weekends to reviewing designs and prototypes.
Anas Chalah, director of instructional laboratories and the safety program at SEAS, arranged for the course to have a large, exclusive lab space adjacent to the rapid prototyping shop in Pierce Hall, where students had easy access to 3-D printing and milling equipment.
The support of Chalah’s staff and facilities allowed students to rapidly iterate through various design concepts and provide the clinical team members with physical prototypes to manipulate and discuss.
And for the students, the course was just the first phase of an ongoing idea translation process.
Graduate students Laura Brattain, Caspar Floryan, and Oliver Hauser earned a publication about their device, which reduces the risk of missing a target during an ultrasound-guided needle biopsy. They have already presented their work at the Wyss Institute and at the annual conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine & Biology Society (EMBC ’11).
Two other groups of students, who designed the dialysis graft resistance adjustment mechanism and a glove that exercises a patient’s finger joints after an injury, are in the process of submitting their work for publication.
Loschak and his teammates have been similarly successful: Through Harvard’s Office of Technology Development, they have applied for a provisional patent on their cranial drill.
ES 227 is a graduate-level course, though undergraduates who have taken ES 51 and have some design experience may enroll. Walsh will teach the course again next spring (he officially takes up his new post Jan. 1).
“The level of interest [in ES 227] was high, the outcome was wonderful, and the fact of the matter is that the students learned a lot,” says Chalah. “I think we’re going to witness an explosion in the number of students who want to take it next spring.”